This was a contemporary art piece on dog fighting I did for my Digital Art class. I apologize its so large, but its easier to see the text that way! I did this piece in Illustrator, by outlining the figure of an emaciated pit bull and adding text on the inside. This piece obviously uses shape
|
Fought by Humans, Banned By Humans, done in illustrator and Photoshop CS6. |
BONUS IMAGE: This was
the original dog I had vectored before adding the text! Sadly it
wouldn't work for the above piece so I had to redraw it, but here it is
any-who.
Also I hope this is okay, this is actually an essay I did for my English class on the same issue, but I think it really hits the nail on the head to show my stance on the banning of Pit Bulls. It's long, but if you're interested, give it a read! (I also have this essay on Turnitin.com the year I did it, which shows proof of my writing this essay, if needed! My English Teacher was also Dr. Smith on this campus.)
Ban
Ignorance
Breed-specific
legislation is a law passed that prohibits or restricts a specific breed of
domesticated animal. This usually more so pertains to a few different types of domesticated
dogs. This law outright bans the possession of these animals or impedes severe
conditions on ownership which must be kept no matter the behavior. These dogs
are legally dangerous; a few of the restrictions include wearing a muzzle at
all times outside of the home, having a permit and displaying warning signs at
the entry way to a person’s home or property. However a ban can cause these dogs
to be forcibly taken away from their owners to be put to sleep if caught within
the area. The most widely known dog to be banned all over the world is the Pit
Bull. They are banned across the United States, Canada, Australia, China, the
United Kingdom and Western Europe. But why are these dogs deemed such dangerous
troublemakers? Being the descendants of bulldogs, Pit’s where for bull baiting
as well as dogfighting. Because of their muscular build, endurance and high
tolerance to physical pain, they are the prime subject for the criminal act of
dogfighting even today. Consequently they are seen as a purely aggressive breed
that is prone to violent behavior. The breed soon found its way at the top of
the list for human fatalities due to dog attacks and dog bites. Many believe
banning these dogs will prevent further attacks. But is it at all what it seems
to be made out to be?
A dog is often the reflection of its
owner and their actions; a neglected, abused or untrained dog can act out just
as a child would if not given the proper attention, care or leadership they
need. The ban on specific dog breeds is cruel and unfair, sending thousands of
dogs to their deaths due to the irresponsible owners who could not properly
take care of their own. Sadly, over 1,000,000 Pit bulls or Pit bull mixes alone
are euthanized every year. This is not to say because they have aggressive tendencies;
in fact most do not show any signs whatsoever. Most do not even bite. But in
this case that does not matter; with the ban all it takes is for a dog too
‘look’ like a Pit bull to get taken away. Though no matter how loving,
affectionate or well behaved the dog has been throughout its life-time; if the
dog shares any resemblance or has pit-like qualities, the city can destroy it
if they deem necessary with no further reason.
The same dog notorious for being dubbed
a mindless, vicious attacker some would hail as the perfect family pet. Many
lost their best friends because of this discriminatory law. One man lost his 8-year old service dog named
Precious due to this law. He suffered from post-traumatic stress disorder and
the dog became essential to help him cope with his disability. Several service
dogs were taken in despite past training and good behavior. An organization
called the American Temperament Test Society put several thousand dogs through standardized
drills designed to test the dog’s stability. Eighty-four of the given pit bulls
passed, being ranked in front of beagles, Airedales, bearded collies and most
all dachshunds. The same apparent trait that makes them excellent fighting dogs
is the same trait that makes them a loving, affectionate pet. They are eager to
please and that same resolute people use to make them fight and act fearless,
is the same resolute they can use to be gentle with anyone. This makes them
fantastic therapy dogs.
But when did all of this hate on the
breed start? Up until the 1980’s there was only one case of a known Pit Bull
attack; however this was only because the male owner intentionally sent his
dogs on the poor victim. Less than a decade later, dog fighting made a huge
comeback with the contribution from rising gangs and drug dealers. Soon to
follow was over thirty communities considering breed specific banning on pit
bulls. There is a clear connection here, yet most all the blame is still set on
the dog breed. These types of people do not care if their dog is confiscated
and killed, they will simply get another one to use for their own entertainment
and greed. The fighting dog is sadly
seen as a disposable item to be used and thrown away when it is no good anymore.
They are bred irresponsibly with only one purpose, to please their masters in
the end who will gamble on their death. In fact, most of these dogs did not
attack their own handlers. They were not bred to fight humans, in fact if a dog
turned on a human it would be put down. No man-eaters where allowed in the dog
fighting world. The fighting dog’s live brutal lives and the only hope they
have is to be ‘rescued’ only to meet a calmer death by an injection. These poor
dog’s where trained and abused into this behavior by their human counterparts
and by no means where born to behave as such.
Moreover one reason pit bull attacks
seemingly began to rise was due to popularity. Not because these dog’s where
becoming more aggressive per say, but that they became more numerous due to
their fame for a period of time. The kinds of dog fatalities change over time,
because so do the breed popularities. For instance, when the popularity of the
pit bull began to fall, so came the rise in Rottweiler and German Shepherd
fatalities because more people where owning these types of dogs.
With this in mind any breed of dog
can develop aggressive or destructive tendencies if not properly handled. There
was one case of a Pomeranian mauling a baby within a few minutes of the girl’s
uncle leaving to fix a bottle for her in the kitchen. She died minutes after
the uncle attempted to revive her. Even the loveable Labrador retriever has
been known to tear a woman’s face off. But they are not banned simply because they
do not have the bad rap pit bulls do. Pit bulls seem to have developed this bad
karma due to the wide abuse of their owners. Certain breeds built like a the
pit bull are more appealing to criminals to use in illegal activities such as
dog fighting and more so end up in the wrong hands. But this again is not the
breeds fault. As Dean Whitehead of Los
Angeles wisely said, “The violence inflicted by mistreated animals, and by
animals that have been trained to fight or attack other animals or humans, is
the responsibility of the owner(s) of the animal. They say that guns don’t kill
people, people kill people. We don’t destroy guns and claim that we’re curbing
violence.” (1)
Harsh breed-specific dog bans are
still being enforced strongly every day and many innocent dogs are murdered
because of it. Stronger enforcements of ANY dog showing aggressive behavior and
not just one breed should hold certain conditions. Any dog can bite when held
by an irresponsible owner. Breeders and adoption agencies should also offer
education to certain breeds that require more attention than others, making
sure the animal is fit for its new home before sending it out. In the end one
would think by now people would have learned to judge by character and not
appearance; but nevertheless not even dogs can seem to escape these human
prejudices even with the use of their cute puppy eyed technique and fluffy
appearance.
Works
Cited
Bastian, Jon. "DOG BEHAVIOR."
CesarsWay.com. Cesar Millan, 16 Mar. 2012. Web. 18 Apr. 2012.
<http://www.cesarsway.com/dogbehavior/basics/How-Did-Pit-Bulls-Get-a-Bad-Rap>.
Cohen, Judy, and John Richardson. "Pit Bull
Panic." Journal Of Popular Culture 36.2 (2002): 285-317. Academic
Search Complete. Web. 17 Apr. 2012.
"Education is key to aggressive dog
issue." Victoria Advocate [Victoria, TX] 7 Apr. 2012. Gale
Opposing Viewpoints In Context. Web. 17 Apr. 2012.
Gladwell, Malcolm. "Troublemakers." New
Yorker 81.46 (2006): 38-43. Academic Search Complete. Web. 17 Apr.
2012.
Greenwood, Arin. "Nuisance Or Necessity? ADA
Suit May Overturn Pit-Bull Bans." ABA Journal 97.9 (2011): 18. Academic
Search Complete. Web. 17 Apr. 2012.
"Man's Best Friend?." Current Events
105.3 (2005): 3. Academic Search Complete. Web. 17 Apr. 2012.
"Parents of savaged boy call for ban on
pitbulls." Sun-Herald [Sydney, Australia] 1 May 2005: 49. Gale
Opposing Viewpoints In Context. Web. 17 Apr. 2012.
"PRO: Banning pit bulls would eliminate breed
responsible for most dog-bite fatalities." Victoria Advocate
[Victoria, TX] 27 Mar. 2011. Gale Opposing Viewpoints In Context. Web.
17 Apr. 2012.